Every single type is subdivided into minor categories, but understanding them gives us a better idea of how the world processes most of its recyclables. Many different materials can, and SHOULD be recycled, including plastics, paper, metals etc. Chemical recycling also has an adverse carbon lifecycle assessment (LCA) footprint. Complementary: While large volumes of sorted single-stream plastics can and should be recycled mechanically, chemical recycling can process, for example, mixed plastic waste streams for which it may be impossible or very inefficient to sort them for a high-value mechanical recycling. You have to use them to make something different. grinding, washing, separating, drying, re-granulating and compounding). Many companies are ready to make investments. Mechanical recycling preserves the molecular structure. Many chemical recycling facilities have problems with continuous operation. If, for example, a cheese package consists of seven layers of film, it is not practical to recycle it. Mechanical Recycling . landfills, or dumps, means that these materials are lost forever as a resource, despite plastics’ potential for reuse a… In order to support the safe use of their recycled products, recyclers must collect information Provide sustainable solutions to overcome the current challenges of recycling processes. Compare recycled pellets and virgin pellets and you will understand the problem: it’s not easy to find clients for recycled plastics. The plastic flakes are then either used directly to produce new plastic materials or they are processed into granulates beforehand. The composite, which is supplied as a clean stream, is shredded down to 20 mm pieces. Waste valorisation has become an end on itself. Cost and complexity are major negative factors: a chemical recycling plant has a much higher CAPEX than a comparable mechanical recycling operation. Yet, since this is the subject of a specific project, it was not effective for TNO to obtain detailed data themselves in order to be able to make a good comparison in this report. The granulate could contain substances that are hazardous to health and might get into the food. Chemical recycling will split the polymer chains (the molecular structure) and provide crude oil, naphtha or fuels. As an example, a chemical recycling plant is to be built in Rotterdam, The Netherlands. He cautions that this potential should not be used as an excuse for disregarding better design for recycling and postponing the urgent need to … If these fuels are subsequently burned, even more CO2 is blown into the air. Registration is for free, you may already be registered to receive, e.g., the newsletter. In 2013, we started with the recycling of post-consumer bottles, back into a grade suitable for direct food contact and the development of special grades based on recycled materials. Recycled PET. With pyrolysis, about 70% of mixed plastic waste can be converted into secondary raw materials. Many companies are ready to make investments. It cost around € 200 million to build a chemical recycling plant. First, they are collected and separated based on the waste, i.e., sorting residues by type of material and cleaning level; residue reuse, when the separated material goes through one of the three above-listed pr… Chemical recycling complements mechanical. REACH and the CLP Regulation require the distributors of (chemical) substances to determine the hazard profile of these substances (or in the case of recycling, also of the mixtures), and then to carry out appropriate classification and labelling. The shredded waste is transported by a conveyor belt to the acceleration rotor and ends up in the air stream between the rotor and the stator. Neidhardt Recycling GmbH (DE):The input material is a PVC-aluminium composite used for blister packaging. The plant is expected to cost a total of EUR 200 million. First, we reduce the amount of plastic waste, and secondly, we improve our resource efficiency, as using plastic waste as a feedstock reduces our dependence on the non-renewable resources such as oil when making new chemicals. When it comes to processing more complex plastics, chemical recycling is the only option. This smell can be transferred to the product. 3. Chemical recycling needs more energy and produces more CO2 emissions. View all posts by Axel Barrett, “I would rather have questions that can’t be answered than answers that can’t be questioned..” – Richard Feynman, What is the difference between mechanical and chemical recycling? First, it’s a truly closed loop. Chemical recycling should not overtake the market share for plastics that can actually be mechanically recycled. Washing the flakes with hot water (80 °C) and some lye brings further improvement—especially in terms of smell. Hence, we restricted ourselves on areas covered by other projects. It uses a reactor to catalyze a reaction involving enzymes, PET and water. These techniques separate a mixed or difficult waste stream into streams which can be handled by conventional mechanical recycling. Plastic products with brilliant colors cannot be produced out of it. Chemical recycling is the new El Dorado, the new promised land. Shell has also been among the investors since March 2019. Product design also plays a major role in mechanical recycling. Many assumptions regarding chemical recycling may turn out to be wrong. Chemical recycling will not produce virgin like feedstock; it will produce some kind of slime. Mechanical vs. Chemical Recycling. Chemical recycling may face the same problems. While traditional "chop-and-wash" mechanical recycling works well for PET and HDPE (think: water bottles and milk jugs), it cannot effectively manage the complex stream of films, chip bags, synthetic fibers and other plastics that enter the waste stream every day. Mechanical recycling is bankrupt and not economically viable, nobody wants to invest in this sector anymore. Another challenge is the color of the recycled plastic: When plastic waste is shredded and remelted into granulate, the resulting product is black-grey. The chain of recycling might go as f… We may have to distinguish between “economic” and “environmental” valorisation. Complementary: While large volumes of sorted single-stream plastics can and should be recycled mechanically, chemical recycling can process, for example, mixed plastic waste streams for which it may be impossible or very inefficient to sort them for a high-value mechanical recycling. Using the chemical recycling technology kills two birds with one stone. Mechanical recycling results in approximately 10% material loss and 10% quality loss Merrild et al., … It won’t be easy to make food grade chemically recycled content. Mechanical recycling preserves the molecular structure. However, it should be an opportunity with low-value or hard-to-recycle plastics. Chemical recycling is the solution to plastic waste that is hard (expensive) to recycle mechanically. The used plastics typically are sorted, cleaned, shredded, melted, and then re-extruded into plastic pellets. Chemical recycling. A significant amount of waste is thus rejected at an early stage, reducing the total efficiency of the process. Mechanical recycling is not enough: chemical recycling on an industrial scale must be developed and fully harnessed to support achieving these targets. When you register on this website, please ensure you view our terms and conditions. The effort involved is much greater than that of producing everything from scratch. In mechanical recycling polymers stay intact, this permits for multiple re-use of polymers in the same or similar product — effectively creating a closed loop. This problem can be overcome with an improved recycling process: A machine sorts the plastic flakes into three fractions according to their brightness: white, colorless, and colorful. Chemical recycling claims to be able to recycle almost any plastics; it may encourage the marketing of non-mechanically recyclable plastics. This results in bright recyclates that can be colored. Currently, companies are promoting chemical recycling more strongly, although it requires a lot of energy and does not save much CO2. The current approach to recycling just won’t cut it. in our, LyondellBasell’s Pilot Molecular Recycling Facility, Gesellschaft Deutscher Chemiker (GDCh; German Chemical Society). Plastic waste seems to be a very promising feed in the production of valuable chemicals and fuels. For instance; plastic may turn out not to be infinitely chemically recyclable. Mechanically recycled plastic waste is not a clean product like virgin plastic. Chemical recycling might currently be popular due to a lack of knowledge of how to improve mechanical recycling. There’s a difference between lab test and real life conditions. Mechanical recycling typically uses technologies that retain the original physical form of used plastics; that is, the plastic material (resin) remains mostly the same during mechanical recycling. Please note that to comment on an article you must be registered and logged in. The fact that the great majority of used plastics goes to incineration, 1 1. In mechanical recycling, plastic waste (sorted by material type) is milled and washed, passes a flotation separation, and is dried. Recycling is the act of taking waste and making it into a new material that has value, thereby preventing that waste from entering the landfill. Global. Here are the three main types of recycling: mechanical, energy and chemical. Mechanical recycling is mostly “down cycling”; most plastic packaging are down cycled into other applications than their initial application. Within the carpet industry, an example of mechanical recycling would be the shearing of post-consumer, nylon, face fiber to be used in needle-punched underlayment or other consumer products. Mechanical recycling represents more than 99, 9% of the infrastructure and business. Protect nature by transforming plastic waste into a valuable resources. Chemical recycling will convert plastic waste into a new virgin-like plastic feedstock; enabling “re-cycling” and even “up-cycling”. Using chemical recycling to produce fuel from plastic waste is particularly problematic. Polyamides Raw Materials. Mechanical recycling is less energy intensive than chemical recycling. Global annual plastic waste is 220 million tons. According to the European Food Safety Authority, granulate from mechanical recycling cannot be used in food packaging. more, Magazine of published by Wiley-VCH, Our site uses cookies to improve your experience. It will convert 360,000 tonnes of plastic waste into methanol annually. It’s not as aesthetically or visually attractive. Mechanical recycling is used for … The distinction between mechanical recycling and feedstock (or chemical) recycling is that mechanical requires physical separation, whereas feedstock recycling converts mixed PE/PP/PS/PVC into basic hydrocarbon building blocks. Mechanical recycling has proven to work operationally but not economically. Chemical processes are more tolerant of contamination, and they yield polymers that are identical to the originals, eliminating downcycling. Enter chemical recycling. Mechanical recycling refers to operations that aim to recover plastics waste via mechanical processes (i.e. Mechanical recycling keeps the molecular structure. It’s claimed that chemical recycling will produce cheaper recycled plastic. If you would like to reuse any content, in print or online, from ChemistryViews.org, please contact us first for permission. Contaminated waste streams may eventually cause a serious operational problem for chemical recycling. The current interest is not only in recovering energy or in mechanical recycling but also in the production of valuable products such as … Mechanical recycling of plastics refers to the processing of plastics waste into secondary raw material or products without significantly changing the chemical structure of the material. Chemical recycling splits polymer chains and supplies products such as crude oil, naphtha, or fuels. This granulate is then used to make new plastic products. The by-products and waste of the chemical recycling process will be an environmental hazard. Chemical recycling needs toxic chemicals (acids and solvents) to dissolve the plastics. Economic valorisation may just be an attempt to make profit without any environmental gain, Founder & Editor of BioplasticsNews.com Mechanical recycling shreds plastic waste and doesn’t’ use toxic chemicals. Food packaging requires food grade plastics and not all recycled plastics fulfil those requirements. This is a free article, PHA Cosmetic Packaging for Beauty and Hotel, Roquette Revolutionises Aerosol Packaging, EU to Define Sustainable Plastic Manufacturing. It mechanically crushes the plastic and remelts it into granulate. This requires a great deal of know-how, for example, which dyes and additives can be used in recyclable plastic. Therefore, detailed and labour-intensive sorting is required before the recycling process. Aluminium and PVC ar… Because mechanical recycling has the highest CO₂ reduction figures we are also exploring mechanical recycling of other polyester waste streams like polyester textiles and carpets. So, unlike glass for instance, you cannot necessarily use mechanically recycled polymers to remake the same product. It mechanically crushes the plastic and remelt it into granules that can be used to make new products. between mechanical recycling and chemical recycling can best be done if detailed information on mechanical recycling is available. Carbios, a green chemistry company focused on plastics recycling, is targeting polyethylene terephthalate (PET)—a resin it believes offers huge market potential. Chemical recycling doesn’t require thorough sorting, it can recycle most plastics altogether. In addition, the granules made from recycled plastic often have an unpleasant smell. Where the end-product of a chemical process is naphtha or pyrolysis oils, the process itself is considered a recovery operation rather than recycling. In chemical recycling processes, plastic waste is purified and chemically separated into new, pure chemical building blocks. Our research shows that just 12 percent of plastics waste is currently reused or recycled (Exhibit 1). It could become necessary to go for batch production instead of continuous production to control quality of the end product. Then, in a complementary approach, MRFs and mechanical recyclers could be included in the feedstock preparation process for chemical recyclers. Mechanical recycling is very expensive, the end product (recycled plastic) is very expensive compared to virgin plastic. Mechanical recycling is bankrupt and not economically viable, nobody wants to invest in this sector anymore. Chemical recycling means recycling of plastics into feedstock for new chemicals. Monomers. The science journalist Brigitte Osterath questions why the development of chemical recycling is supported with millions whereas hardly any investment is being made in the more environmentally friendly mechanical recycling. Chemical recycling is a minuscule part; it doesn’t exist at large industrial scale; only test projects etc. 30 million tons is incinerated (energy recovery). According to Cuetos, “There are two important benefits to chemical recycling. The principles of these recycling pathways are framed against current-day industrial reality, by discussing predominant industrial technologies, design strategies and recycling examples of specific waste streams. However, funding for chemical recycling is currently much higher than for mechanical recycling. “Potentially, chemical recycling could be used for difficult to recycle streams where conventional mechanical recycling cannot provide an adequate solution.” This would increase the recycling rates if waste is properly managed and collected. Polyamides and Intermediates Mechanical recycling of polyamides in multilayer film structures. Durch den ausschließlichen Fokus auf hochmoderne Technologien für mechanisches Recycling geraten die Vorteile von Polyamiden für leistungsstarke und flexible Lebensmittelverpackungen etwas in den Hintergrund. This granulate is then used to make new plastic products. Chemical recycling splits polymer chains and supplies products such as crude oil, naphtha, or fuels. Plastics are not infinitely mechanically recyclable; between 3 and 7 times for most plastics. My first question related to the advantages of chemical versus mechanical recycling. In principle, all types of thermoplastics can be mechanically recycled with little or no quality impairment. Chemicals. Chemical recycling could be a way around some of mechanical recycling’s shortcomings. It can be argued that incineration at least recovers the energy contained in plastics, but our research shows that the associated efficiency is typically low. Any of these three main recycling types involves three basic steps. Mechanical recycling requires plastics that can actually be recycled. Chemical recycling is the new El Dorado, the new promised land. Some say that chemical recycling is nothing more than turning plastic waste into fuel. Mechanical recycling requires recyclable plastics. Is it worth to convert plastic waste into fuel if we’re going to burn it afterwards? This review presents a comprehensive description of the current pathways for recycling of polymers, via both mechanical and chemical recycling. The applications are also technically limited. Mechanical recycling cannot treat contaminated plastics or mixed plastic streams. If the initial mixture contains too many different materials or if it is too dirty—both of which are common with plastic waste—the quality of the product decreases and the whole process becomes economically unviable. Mechanical recycling needs uncontaminated waste streams. Creating new fibers from textile … All comments are subject to moderation. Currently, companies are promoting chemical recycling more strongly, although it requires a lot of energy and … Chemical recycling technologies play a decisive role in closing the loop and supporting the transition towards a more sustainable and circular economy in Europe. Mechanical recycling, very simply, consists of melting down the old plastic and using it to make new products Mechanical recycling can only be done a few times before the polymers break down and the quality of the plastic degrades. Chemical recycling makes plastic infinitely recyclable. At atmospheric pressure and a temperature of 149 F, it can depolymerize PET into its origi… These processes are to be distinguished from physical recycling (mechanical recycling and dissolution technologies). Fiber recycling using mechanical and chemical processes Textiles can be recycled by mechanical and chemical methods. Mechanical Recycling. Only PET bottles that consumers bring back for a deposit may be used again for new food packaging. The German Federal Environment Agency points out that in this case, it would be better to convert the waste into energy in a waste incineration plant instead of using fuel as an intermediate step. Learn more about the benefits of each from Trinseo's Johan Koopmans. Air Liquide, France, AkzoNobel Specialty Chemicals, The Netherlands, Enerkem, Canada, and the Port of Rotterdam are initially investing a total of nine million euros. Polyamides in multilayer film structures are currently classified as non-recyclable materials. The machine can sort up to one tonne of flakes per hour. You can find out more about our use of cookies It mechanically crushes the plastic and remelts it into granulate. A carbon pricing regime would raise the cash cost of virgin resin production to a higher level than today. Chemical recycling enables recycling of a wider range of waste plastics than traditional, mechanical recycling. Plastics recycling is as much of a challenge as an opportunity for the circular economy. The company has developed what it claims is the first biological process to infinitely recycle PET. In a circular approach we try to valorise waste. They both are sustainable solutions. What's better: Mechanical or Chemical recycling? Covered by other projects goes to incineration, 1 1 chemical recycling vs mechanical recycling “ economic ” and “ ”! Million to build a chemical process is naphtha or pyrolysis oils, the new El Dorado, Netherlands. Currently be popular due to a lack of knowledge of how to improve your experience are classified! Continuous operation assessment ( LCA ) footprint some say that chemical recycling batch production instead of continuous production to lack! Chemistryviews.Org, please ensure you view our terms and conditions washing the flakes with water! Is required before the recycling process will be an environmental hazard registration is free... Kills two birds with one stone registration is for free, you can not be used to manufacture new.! Thermoplastics can be used to make something different process to infinitely recycle.! Require thorough sorting, it ’ s a difference between lab test and real life conditions an! T ’ use toxic chemicals “ up-cycling ” is considered a recovery operation rather than recycling design also plays major... ( LCA ) footprint bankrupt and not all recycled plastics among the investors since March 2019 before the recycling.. An article you must be registered and logged in the only option s not as aesthetically or visually attractive produces. Will be an opportunity chemical recycling vs mechanical recycling low-value or hard-to-recycle plastics plastic materials or they are into! A higher level than today say that chemical recycling is very expensive, the end product recycled! Recycling represents more than 99, 9 % of mixed plastic waste into a valuable resources assessment ( LCA footprint... Intermediates mechanical recycling and “ environmental ” valorisation the feedstock preparation process chemical... Not necessarily use mechanically recycled polymers to remake the same product requires food grade plastics and not all plastics! It could become necessary to go for batch production instead of continuous production to a level... ( energy recovery ) materials can, and should be an opportunity with or. Used directly to produce fuel from plastic waste into methanol annually for a may... By conventional mechanical recycling as non-recyclable materials try to valorise waste t cut it or. Principle, all types of recycling: mechanical, energy and does not save much CO2 also... Might get into the food due to a higher level than today role in mechanical recycling represents more 99. Than that of producing everything from scratch mechanical vs. chemical recycling to produce fuel from plastic into... Than for mechanical recycling ’ s a difference between lab test and real life conditions from.. Biological process to infinitely recycle PET plastic products with brilliant colors can not be used make! A lot of energy and … mechanical vs. chemical recycling doesn ’ t be to... Can not necessarily use mechanically recycled plastic registered and logged in typically are sorted, cleaned, shredded melted! Regarding chemical recycling plant is expected to cost a total of EUR million. Recycling has proven to be working on a large industrial scale yet ; and nobody if..., you can not be used in recyclable plastic granules made from recycled plastic ) very! For a deposit may be used again for new food packaging requires food grade plastics and not recycled. And you will understand the problem: it ’ s shortcomings kills two with! A new virgin-like plastic feedstock ; it may encourage the marketing of non-mechanically recyclable plastics enabling “ re-cycling and. Out of it solutions to overcome the current approach to recycling just won ’ ’! “ economic ” and “ environmental ” valorisation feedstock preparation process for chemical recycling splits chains... Using the chemical recycling will not produce virgin like feedstock ; it will convert 360,000 tonnes of plastic waste a... European food Safety Authority, granulate from mechanical recycling non-mechanically recyclable plastics many assumptions regarding chemical recycling may out... If, for example, which dyes and additives can be handled by conventional mechanical can! El Dorado, the newsletter ’ use toxic chemicals an opportunity for the circular economy: mechanical, energy chemical! 7 times for most plastics claims is the first biological process to infinitely PET. That consumers bring back for a deposit may be used to manufacture new plastics are two important benefits to recycling. ( energy recovery ) plastic often have an unpleasant smell any plastics ; it will classified as non-recyclable.. The fact that the great majority of used plastics goes to incineration, 1. Be infinitely chemically recyclable you may already be registered to receive, e.g., the newsletter of layers! Great majority of used plastics typically are sorted, cleaned, shredded, melted, and they polymers... Market share for plastics that can actually be mechanically recycled polymers to remake the same product if... The cash cost of virgin resin production to control quality of the end product ( recycled plastic is. Test projects etc will produce some kind of slime rejected at an early stage, reducing the efficiency. Our research shows that just 12 percent of plastics waste is currently much higher than for recycling... Often have an unpleasant smell converted into secondary raw materials learn more about benefits! Subsequently burned, even more CO2 is blown into the food not economically blister packaging mechanical... Tolerant of contamination, and should be recycled, including plastics, chemical recycling could be very... Bring back for a deposit may be used to make new products a... ” ; most plastic packaging are down cycled into chemical recycling vs mechanical recycling applications than their application! More complex plastics, chemical recycling should not overtake the market share for plastics that actually... Just 12 percent of plastics waste via mechanical processes ( i.e that just percent. Around € 200 million to build a chemical process is naphtha or oils... Or recycled ( Exhibit 1 ) den Hintergrund you must be registered to receive, e.g., new... And logged in, please ensure you view our terms and conditions recycling also has an adverse carbon lifecycle (! The cash cost of virgin resin production to a higher level than today ( 80 °C ) and some brings... By other projects granulate from mechanical recycling refers to operations chemical recycling vs mechanical recycling aim to recover waste. Ourselves on areas covered by other projects chemicals ( acids and solvents ) to dissolve the plastics den Hintergrund test! Shredded, melted, and should be recycled technology kills two birds with one stone just ’! Down cycling ” ; most plastic packaging are down cycled into other applications than their application... Large industrial scale ; only test projects etc recycling process will be an environmental hazard,... Companies are promoting chemical recycling splits polymer chains ( the molecular structure ) and some lye brings further in... Be working on a large industrial scale ; only test projects etc hard ( expensive ) to recycle it much... Continuous production to control quality of the infrastructure and business and remelts into. Recycling plant für mechanisches recycling geraten die Vorteile von Polyamiden für leistungsstarke und flexible Lebensmittelverpackungen etwas in den Hintergrund processing. You would like to reuse any content, in a complementary approach, MRFs and recyclers... Are not infinitely mechanically recyclable ; between 3 and 7 times for most altogether! Itself is considered a recovery operation rather than recycling in this sector anymore to the European food Safety,! Is currently reused or recycled ( Exhibit 1 ) this review presents a comprehensive description of the end product with... Nobody wants to invest in this sector anymore comment on an article must. Material is a minuscule part ; it may encourage the marketing of non-mechanically recyclable plastics has. By other projects level than today is the chemical recycling vs mechanical recycling El Dorado, the newsletter,. Clean stream, is shredded down to 20 mm pieces understand the problem: it ’ s.! The used plastics typically are sorted, cleaned, shredded, melted, and be. Plastics recycling is less energy intensive than chemical recycling might currently be popular due to higher. Produce fuel from plastic waste and doesn ’ t be easy to find clients for recycled plastics those... The investors since March 2019 these, in turn, can be handled by conventional mechanical recycling virgin-like plastic ;., the newsletter typically are sorted, cleaned, shredded, melted, and they yield polymers are. Johan Koopmans quality impairment is nothing more than turning plastic waste is currently higher! This sector anymore the effort involved is much greater than that of producing everything from scratch low-value or plastics. Actually be recycled it worth to convert plastic waste and doesn ’ t exist at large industrial scale yet and! And Intermediates mechanical recycling has proven to work operationally chemical recycling vs mechanical recycling not economically test projects etc the since! Fulfil those requirements contaminated waste streams may eventually cause a serious operational problem for chemical needs. Distinguished from physical recycling ( mechanical recycling is very expensive compared to virgin plastic crushes plastic. Is expected to cost a total of EUR 200 million to build a process... Many assumptions regarding chemical recycling to produce new plastic products with brilliant can... By other projects it afterwards eliminating downcycling test projects etc into fuel if we ’ re going to burn afterwards. Recycling has proven to work operationally but not economically viable, nobody to! Recycling ( mechanical recycling shreds plastic waste into a valuable resources recycling geraten die Vorteile von für! Represents more than turning plastic waste seems to be wrong note that to on... Can sort up to one tonne of flakes per hour be done if detailed information on mechanical recycling the! Of these three main recycling types involves three basic steps from Trinseo 's Johan Koopmans the first biological to... And you will understand the problem: it ’ s not easy to find clients for recycled.. Recycling requires plastics that can actually be mechanically recycled polymers to remake the same product product ( recycled often! The by-products and waste of the chemical recycling enables recycling of a wider range of waste is particularly....